Can You Toast Sweet Potatoes in a Toaster?

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster? I find out!

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

Have you seen the newest Internet rage? It’s sweet potato toast and it’s taking over Instagram.

I love the idea of sweet potato toast. I’m always looking for ways to get more vegetables into our day, so I thought I’d give it a go.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

I started by slicing a sweet potato as thin as I could using a mandolin. Then I popped two slices into the toaster and used the highest setting per the advice of the world wide web.

This is how my toasted sweet potato turned out:

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

I had to stop the toast when I smelled burning.

I figured the sweet potato was sliced too thin. That’s when I decided I would hand cut the sweet potato a bit thicker and try again.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

Again, I set the toaster to high to toast my sweet potato slices. I’ll remind you, this is what the recipe on the Internet says to do.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

As you can see, the ends, where the sweet potato was thin, were totally burnt. I cut that part away and gave the remaining middle part to my two trusty sweet potato toast testers.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

We all agreed the center was under done.

Burnt edges. Under done center. Gross.

I then decided I would toast it on the highest setting once, then lower the toast setting by half, and toast it a second time, knowing I would have burnt edges that I would need to cut away.

That plan did not work.

I tried 3 more times to actually toast a sweet potato before I gave up. There was no combination of heat and slicing that actually produced anything resembling toast.

That’s when I though I’d give the microwave a try.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

Big mistake. BIG.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

I was not about to give up. There had to be a way. It’s all over the Internet!

I gave it one more try. This time I opted to use the broiler. I lined up a few slices on the broiler pan and broiled them on high for a little over 3 minutes.

Can you really toast sweet potatoes in a toaster?

Finally! It worked! I made sweet potato “toast” in the oven on broil – not in my toaster!

The broiler worked to thoroughly cook the sweet potato with minimal amount of burning. Plus, I could slice the sweet potato a bit on the thick side so it could easily take toppings.

How to really make sweet potato toast. No, not in the toaster.

We smeared our sweet potato toast with almond butter then topped with a sliced banana and a drizzle of honey and a sprinkling of cinnamon.

Have you tried to toast sweet potatoes in a toaster? What were your results?

Are You Tired of Processed Crap?

Subscribe Today and Download My Free Healthy Grocery List. It's your cheatsheet to a less processed life. Then, each week, I'll help you take charge of your health by emailing you the best real food recipes and non-toxic DIYs.

Powered by ConvertKit

Tired of Processed Crap?

Make the switch to healthy, real food and non-toxic products. SIGN-UP to find out how!
This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy here.

Comments

  1. Thank you for this post! when I first heard about ‘sweet potato toast’, I cringed at the thought of putting them into my tosater, lol.

Leave a Comment

*